Genomic TPI Comparison List 2010 vs 2011

This analysis of Genomic proof data compares Jan 2010 evaluations with no daughter data versus December 2011 evaluations which now include daughter data. The discussion of this comparison is published on pages 74 & 75 of the January Holstein World.

For those concerned with the small changes made in the TPI formula in April 2010 we provide the official explanation from Holstein USA

In order to keep the mean TPI and its spread (standard deviation) constant, we need to update two values, i.e., the 1815 (to update the mean) and 3.7 (to equalize the spread). The new updated values are 1832 and 3.8. By updating the formula with the values 1832 and 3.8, our TPI values will be directly comparable to the old values, allowing breeders to more easily see how the change in trait weightings impacted each individual animal.

Filter
REG Num Std Code YRel10 NM$10 $Rk10 TRel10 TPI10 TPIRk10
YREL11 NM$11 $Rk11 TRel11 TPI11 TPIRk11
NM$Chg TPIChg
137611441 1HO9167 72 671 9 69 2132 22
93 699 1 91 2180 1
28 48
62253367 29HO13846 72 744 2 68 2385 1
92 629 3 87 2144 2
-115 -241
138550394 1HO2531 71 517 45 68 2086 32
85 515 14 76 2135 3
-2 49
63026939 1HO9527 71 614 19 68 2104 30
89 631 2 75 2126 4
17 22
62942427 1HO9192 72 691 7 66 2304 3
92 552 10 88 2104 5
-139 -200
53557278 7HO10176 71 755 1 68 2327 2
82 565 9 76 2081 6
-190 -246
62916235 11HO10017 72 667 10 68 2148 18
92 590 5 90 2074 7
-77 -74
64009082 1HO2565 72 694 5 68 2205 13
82 597 4 77 2057 8
-97 -148
138372105 200HO2331 72 598 22 69 2231 9
86 416 32 79 2041 9
-182 -190
62792933 1HO9225 72 509 47 68 1996 58
92 529 12 89 2001 10
20 5
138685522 14HO5936 72 388 88 68 1926 77
85 370 45 74 1996 11
-18 70
63811814 1HO9593 72 371 92 68 1868 89
88 444 28 78 1995 12
73 127
7611374 11HO9956 72 560 32 68 2129 23
93 457 26 91 1994 13
-103 -135
138680189 14HO5954 72 695 4 68 2207 12
87 535 11 79 1989 14
-160 -218
63262903 1HO9543 72 486 55 68 2106 28
90 389 40 82 1989 15
-97 -117
138122625 94HO13666 73 637 15 70 2255 6
95 361 54 88 1977 16
-276 -278
64631968 1HO2571 72 694 6 68 2234 8
85 464 24 76 1965 17
-230 -269
65602047 1HO2584 71 430 73 68 1941 72
84 424 30 75 1961 19
-6 20
137959538 11HO10079 72 483 56 69 2074 34
92 374 43 89 1961 18
-109 -113
64287983 7HO10011 72 636 16 69 2253 7
90 417 31 81 1951 20
-219 -302
443047659 11HO9951 72 629 17 66 2045 44
86 582 6 79 1948 21
-47 -97
62768984 1HO9315 72 597 23 68 2018 52
92 517 13 89 1940 22
-80 -78
62026685 29HO13811 72 599 21 69 2118 25
90 456 27 84 1938 23
-143 -180
137801143 76HO569 72 546 37 69 2017 53
86 463 25 81 1933 24
-83 -84
103472256 200HO5660 72 565 31 68 2109 26
89 477 21 83 1927 25
-88 -182
62968892 76HO567 73 554 33 69 2108 27
96 367 48 92 1926 26
-187 -182
62658226 29HO13426 73 454 63 70 2063 41
89 313 69 82 1926 27
-141 -137
8956383 7HO9893 73 412 80 69 2032 47
86 289 74 76 1924 28
-123 -108
53452462 7HO10021 71 663 11 68 2146 19
87 513 15 76 1921 29
-150 -225
63285292 1HO9659 73 422 76 70 1981 61
90 343 59 84 1917 30
-79 -64
137012381 200HO5567 73 424 74 70 2028 50
89 300 71 82 1915 31
-124 -113
61898307 1HO8919 73 549 35 73 1979 63
87 500 16 83 1909 32
-49 -70
137659689 76HO514 72 597 24 69 2201 14
86 363 50 82 1907 33
-234 -294
62496434 200HO5668 72 572 30 69 2153 16
92 391 38 91 1904 34
-181 -249
62175932 1HO9208 72 715 3 68 2296 4
94 401 34 90 1898 35
-314 -398
137566675 1HO9298 73 578 29 69 1995 59
91 571 7 79 1894 37
-7 -101
420132800 11HO9939 72 596 26 66 2151 17
93 394 36 89 1894 36
-202 -257
63082462 1HO2543 72 461 60 68 1978 64
83 387 41 72 1894 38
-74 -84
63285306 1HO9673 72 530 40 66 2028 48
90 485 20 80 1889 40
-45 -139
429390128 11HO9879 71 542 38 67 2055 42
92 359 55 90 1889 39
-183 -166
137367221 200HO2272 72 593 27 69 2195 15
90 358 56 84 1885 41
-235 -310
63262902 1HO9544 72 519 43 68 2141 20
91 362 53 84 1884 42
-157 -257
64964550 200HO5868 72 503 49 69 1941 73
85 470 22 79 1883 43
-33 -58
62617936 29HO13454 72 647 13 69 2223 10
93 398 35 91 1879 44
-249 -344
136862228 1HO8987 72 420 77 69 2004 57
92 327 66 79 1875 45
-93 -129
62848153 11HO9898 72 627 18 68 2068 38
91 491 18 89 1874 46
-136 -194
137835643 1HO9554 72 518 44 69 2037 46
91 370 44 86 1870 47
-148 -167
7588022 200HO5575 73 434 71 68 1902 85
92 368 47 88 1862 48
-66 -40
137922325 200HO2248 72 450 66 68 1964 66
89 336 63 81 1860 49
-114 -104
138399478 1HO9528 72 501 51 66 1913 83
90 491 19 83 1857 50
-10 -56
62564884 1HO9137 72 608 20 68 2073 35
93 499 17 90 1852 51
-109 -221
62365568 1HO9103 72 597 25 68 2013 54
94 570 8 90 1844 52
-27 -169
138929389 11HO10309 72 439 68 69 1898 86
82 411 33 76 1843 53
-28 -55
63685691 7HO9879 72 643 14 69 2287 5
95 336 62 89 1841 54
-307 -446
62563777 11HO9798 72 582 28 68 2120 24
93 394 37 90 1838 55
-188 -282
103680069 200HO5658 72 504 48 68 2080 33
90 294 72 83 1831 56
-210 -249
137302783 7HO10039 72 405 81 69 1920 79
95 292 73 92 1822 57
-113 -98
8930027 200HO2366 72 550 34 68 2069 37
89 318 68 81 1816 58
-232 -253
63082424 11HO10149 72 404 83 68 1818 101
91 431 29 86 1815 59
27 -3
63392242 14HO5880 72 653 12 68 2139 21
91 467 23 83 1814 60
-186 -325
7876687 200HO3570 73 452 64 69 2028 49
90 268 79 83 1810 61
-184 -218
103939456 200HO5645 74 490 54 71 2067 40
93 274 77 83 1799 62
-216 -268
62114100 14HO5843 72 524 42 68 2005 56
91 335 64 86 1792 63
-189 -213
62398872 1HO9092 73 498 52 70 2040 45
93 363 52 89 1788 64
-135 -252
139141470 7HO10000 72 228 111 68 1673 115
79 340 60 71 1784 65
112 111
52475507 11HO9911 72 548 36 69 2013 55
94 391 39 90 1781 66
-157 -232
62914077 506HO222 72 400 85 68 1830 98
86 369 46 80 1779 67
-31 -51
137479377 1HO9188 73 432 72 70 1924 78
94 343 58 91 1778 69
-89 -146
62175933 29HO13517 72 683 8 68 2219 11
93 336 61 90 1778 68
-347 -441
137117273 11HO9930 72 373 90 69 1926 76
94 241 83 89 1774 70
-132 -152
62496432 29HO13973 72 533 39 69 2070 36
92 308 70 85 1771 71
-225 -299
63683035 11HO10022 72 493 53 69 2020 51
91 272 78 87 1771 72
-221 -249
63262904 1HO9493 73 513 46 69 1936 75
91 363 51 86 1769 73
-150 -167
61898426 200HO5663 73 420 78 70 2068 39
89 179 97 83 1766 74
-241 -302
7925737 80HO323 73 331 99 69 1819 100
85 258 80 79 1764 75
-73 -55
50840890 76HO551 73 333 97 70 1814 102
91 252 81 87 1763 76
-81 -51
138241999 76HO590 72 275 107 69 1790 103
80 219 88 75 1761 78
-56 -29
137145290 76HO588 72 481 57 69 2100 31
83 169 101 79 1761 77
-312 -339
62744607 147HO2244 73 261 109 70 1837 97
82 151 104 77 1757 79
-110 -80
63563637 11HO10204 72 466 59 68 1905 84
90 384 42 81 1755 80
-82 -150
137821772 1HO9276 72 437 69 66 1943 71
92 280 76 89 1754 81
-157 -189
103506674 200HO5623 73 529 41 70 1981 62
90 364 49 83 1751 82
-165 -230
62188592 147HO1197 72 393 86 69 1917 82
88 241 82 77 1751 83
-152 -166
137471203 76HO512 72 402 84 69 1917 80
86 238 84 78 1735 84
-164 -182
62437648 7HO10391 72 302 104 69 1780 104
87 281 75 81 1727 85
-21 -53
137668966 76HO566 73 320 102 70 1722 111
87 350 57 82 1726 86
30 4
62650804 506HO220 73 329 100 70 1858 93
87 179 98 76 1714 87
-150 -144
137477179 1HO9248 73 423 75 69 1960 67
91 234 85 86 1702 88
-189 -258
62626454 200HO3512 72 405 82 69 1951 70
89 180 96 83 1701 89
-225 -250
136722780 76HO545 73 267 108 70 1710 112
92 232 86 89 1698 90
-35 -12
8932152 200HO3603 72 374 89 69 1917 81
87 146 106 81 1694 91
-228 -223
137842384 11HO10067 72 392 87 68 1852 95
92 324 67 89 1681 92
-68 -171
137221291 76HO550 72 44 119 69 1546 119
92 69 113 85 1681 93
25 135
63164321 11HO10153 73 288 106 69 1867 90
91 40 115 85 1679 94
-248 -188
7807925 80HO1085 72 306 103 69 1845 96
91 197 93 80 1678 95
-109 -167
61267071 11HO9711 72 362 93 69 1763 106
93 330 65 88 1676 96
-32 -87
137583573 1HO9184 72 442 67 69 1986 60
91 198 92 86 1672 97
-244 -314
64251021 76HO577 73 261 110 69 1773 105
81 171 100 72 1667 98
-90 -106
103974966 200HO5630 72 503 50 68 2105 29
89 111 109 82 1665 99
-392 -440
53298118 29HO13383 73 451 65 69 1978 65
95 221 87 91 1661 100
-230 -317
61691015 200HO5643 72 171 117 68 1726 110
88 82 112 81 1657 101
-89 -69
137156663 11HO9900 72 293 105 69 1729 109
94 204 90 89 1650 102
-89 -79
437563550 11HO9945 72 437 70 67 1956 68
92 203 91 89 1647 103
-234 -309
138411053 11HO10181 72 345 95 68 1755 108
91 190 94 86 1640 105
-155 -115
137187496 29HO13477 72 458 61 69 2047 43
94 189 95 91 1640 104
-269 -407
62207145 29HO13352 73 324 101 69 1860 91
96 153 103 92 1623 106
-171 -237
137625769 76HO564 72 373 91 69 1954 69
87 128 107 82 1613 107
-245 -341
62297922 11HO9917 73 471 58 69 1855 94
93 204 89 89 1608 108
-267 -247
62188614 147HO1198 72 333 98 69 1822 99
89 125 108 77 1603 109
-208 -219
63042030 54HO426 72 360 94 69 1860 92
87 87 111 77 1591 110
-273 -269
61898423 7HO9165 73 184 114 70 1877 88
96 -99 120 93 1585 111
-283 -292
62661896 1HO9204 72 458 62 68 1936 74
89 169 102 84 1560 112
-289 -376
137294042 76HO552 72 175 116 69 1686 113
89 62 114 81 1535 113
-113 -151
137187517 11HO9912 72 420 79 69 1887 87
94 176 99 88 1518 114
-244 -369
7660182 80HO1081 72 199 112 67 1638 116
89 40 116 82 1492 115
-159 -146
7986987 80HO1084 72 104 118 67 1571 117
88 12 118 82 1488 116
-92 -83
61973589 7HO10400 72 184 115 69 1679 114
84 18 117 81 1474 117
-166 -205
136875639 94HO869 73 193 113 69 1557 118
93 150 105 86 1453 119
-43 -104
62175839 11HO9748 74 335 96 71 1763 107
94 97 110 89 1453 118
-238 -310
137892772 7HO9552 73 -65 121 70 1492 120
98 -236 121 96 1382 120
-171 -110
62547850 506HO221 72 -23 120 68 1382 121
87 -82 119 78 1348 121
-59 -34


8740 55135
8305 238704

10863 38485
10136 218133

-16650 -20571
Sires ranked by Dec 2011 TPI
 72 456
69 1973

90 318
84 1803

-138 -170